Skip to content
Gerard Canada Stone Coated Steel Roofing

Comparisons

Stone-Coated Steel vs. Asphalt Shingles: An Honest Comparison

Asphalt shingles are still the most common roof in Ontario, and for good reason: they are familiar and inexpensive up front. Stone-coated steel costs more to install, but it is built for a much longer service life. Here is how the two compare.

What each one is

Asphalt shingles are mats coated in asphalt and surfaced with mineral granules. Stone-coated steel roofing uses formed steel panels with a bonded layer of stone granules, so it keeps a textured, natural look rather than the shine of bare metal.

Service life and warranties

Asphalt roofs in Ontario are commonly replaced after a couple of decades or less, depending on the product, ventilation and exposure. Stone-coated steel is chosen for a much longer service life. Our roofs come with a 50-year transferable product warranty and our own 12-year labour workmanship warranty, both subject to written terms. The written warranty is the most reliable guide to what a product is designed for.

Appearance

Because of the stone granules, stone-coated steel can look like shake, tile or shingle. Gerard Shake PRO, for example, is designed to recreate the depth of hand-split cedar shake.

Weight

Steel panels are generally lighter than many traditional roofing materials. We assess your existing structure and decking on site before recommending a system.

Upfront cost vs. long-term cost

Asphalt usually costs less to install. The case for stone-coated steel rests on not having to replace the roof again for a very long time, plus a transferable warranty that can be a selling point if you move.

Maintenance

Neither roof is completely maintenance-free. Keeping eavestrough clear, checking flashing and looking at the roof after severe storms is good practice for both. See our metal roof maintenance guide for a simple routine.

This guide is general information for homeowners. Product specifications, warranties and promotions are subject to the applicable written terms. Ask us about your specific roof.

Free, no-obligation estimate

Ready for a roof built to last?

Tell us about your home. We’ll arrange an on-site assessment and a clear written estimate.

Call Now Free Estimate